Maine Supreme Court Hands Major Defeat to MERS Mortgage Registry


Maine Supreme Court Hands Major Defeat to MERS Mortgage Registry

Posted on July 8, 2014 by Yves Smith

Yesterday, we wrote about a major loss by the electronic mortgage registry, MERS, in a major Federal court case in Pennsylvania. MERS suffered an additional blow via an important adverse decision in the Maine Supreme Court, against Tom Cox, the attorney who first made robosigning a national issue.

Because mortgage abuses have faded from national headlines, some readers may not be familiar with MERS. MERS was created to replace the system of local recording of mortgages. While such an idea could have had merit (for instance, Australia has a national mortgage registry that by all accounts works well), MERS was designed for the convenience of banks and mortgage securitizers, with no review of how it would work with well-established real estate law in 50 states. MERS is a classic example of what Lambert calls “code as law” where computer systems are put in place and contracts and legal precedents are expected to conform to the dictates of often-not-well-enough-designed “innovations”. And even worse, in the case of MERS, the database protocols fall shockingly short of well-established norms for information integrity and security.

It is important to remember that with over 60 million mortgages in MERS, the records that show ownership and liens against many Americans’ biggest asset are in serious doubt. Yet astonishingly, MERS has been able to maintain a facade of legitimacy, mainly by settling cases that looked to pose a threat to its operations. However, a few important challenges have crept through. One was a case filed on behalf of all Pennsylvania county recorders. If it survives appeal, it will deal a fatal blow to the use of MERS in that state, will almost certainly result in large damages, and will have serious ramifications in other so-called “title theory” states.

The Maine victory by Thomas Cox is more decisive, in that MERS has no where to go in Maine after losing in the Supreme Court. Its full ramifications are not fully clear, however. We’ve embedded the ruling below.

As the justices explain, the initial filing in Bank of America v. Greenleaf was a mess, leading the court to sanction the attorney. Nevertheless, BofA was able to muster enough of an argument to win a judgment against the borrower. Greenleaf appealed. The case made its way to the Supreme Court, with the argument focused on standing, as in whether Bank of America had the right to foreclose in the first place. The Supreme Court agreed that the bank had established that it was the holder of the note (the borrower IOU) in that it had possession of a note endorsed in blank. But the court stated that that was insufficient, and it also had to establish that it had “requisite interest” in the mortgage. Bank of America tried to show that through documents that showed that the Greenleafs had signed a mortgage with RMS, a lender, and MERS as the lender’s nominee. Another record showed that, as the court put it, “MERS purports to assign the mortgage to BAC” in 2011. The Supreme Court found that this did not pass muster.

Read More:



Want Worldwide PEACE and Prosperity. We are the solution we have been searching for... Free People on Earth will solve our crisis and create an era of Creativity. Be Aware; Be Creative; Be Active; Be Free; and then Share it. LOVE & Wholeness AMOR y Paz

Tagged with: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
Posted in Take 'em to COURT

Please Contribute a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 395 other followers
The Worldwide Awakening
Peaceful Awareness & Knowledge Based TransitionSeptember 11, 2017
Exercise freedom and creativity for all Earth’s inhabitants to explore ready breakthroughs in Self Organizing Communities, economics, and technology. This is a D.I.Y. project
State Sponsored Terror
The Big Day ReportMarch 30, 2018
Institutions of crime Big days have come, gone, and come again (Manipulations: Market Exchanges crash, wars, government Elections, and Taxation). Search for what is hidden and for what is not spoken. What secrets are hidden in Antarctica? Be Aware of the next big Day for fraudulent institutions.
Peace Today

Peace Today

RonMamita’s Blog
July 2014
All posts here
Audio coming soon!
%d bloggers like this: